What Is the Average Clause, and How Can Underinsurance Reduce Your Claim?
The average clause, also called a co-insurance clause or averaging provision, reduces your claim payout in proportion to how much you’re underinsured. If your business property is worth $1 million but insured for $600,000, the insurer may pay only 60% of any claim, even a small partial one. It’s common in business insurance, and the 80% safety buffer many people have heard of only protects homes, not business property.
This guide explains how the average clause works, the legal rules in Australia, worked examples, and how to reduce the risk of it applying to you.
How does the average clause work?
If you insure property for less than its full value, the insurer treats you as carrying the uninsured share of every loss yourself. When you claim, the payout is reduced by the same proportion you’re underinsured.
The basic formula is:
Payout = (sum insured ÷ full value of the property) × amount of the loss
It applies to partial losses, not just total losses. That’s the part that catches businesses out: a burst pipe or a small fire can be reduced, even though the claim is well inside your sum insured.
Average clause example
A warehouse would cost $1,000,000 to rebuild. The owner insures it for $600,000, and a fire causes $100,000 of damage.
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Full rebuild value | $1,000,000 |
| Sum insured | $600,000 (60%) |
| Damage | $100,000 |
| Insurer pays (60% of the loss) | $60,000, less the excess |
| Owner pays | $40,000, plus the excess |
The owner is out of pocket $40,000 on a claim worth a tenth of the sum insured.
Does the 80% rule protect business property?
No. Under section 44 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984, if a home building or home contents is insured for at least 80% of its value, the insurer can’t reduce a claim using an average clause. If it’s below 80%, the reduction is calculated against 80% of the value rather than the full value, which softens it.
That protection only applies to a building used mainly as a residence by the insured and their family, or its contents. It doesn’t apply to commercial buildings, business contents, stock, machinery or business interruption. An investment property you rent out isn’t your residence, so check how your landlord policy treats underinsurance too.
For business policies, the law requires the insurer to clearly inform you in writing of the nature and effect of any average clause before you take out the policy. Check your policy documents for an average or underinsurance clause, and make sure your values are right.
What types of insurance have an average clause?
Average clauses are typically found in business insurance, including:
- Commercial building insurance: owned or leased commercial property.
- Business contents: equipment, furniture, fit-out and stock.
- Business interruption: loss of income after damage, where the sum insured is based on gross profit or revenue.
- Industrial special risks (ISR): larger commercial and industrial property policies, which commonly include an 85% or 80% underinsurance clause.
The wording varies. Some policies apply average on a straight proportion, as in the example above. ISR policies based on the standard Mark IV wording apply it only if your declared value is below 85% of the property’s actual value, and some insurers modify this to 80%. Many also waive average for small claims, such as losses under 5% or 10% of the declared value. Check the average or underinsurance condition in your own policy.
Co-insurance clause example (80% threshold)
Where a business policy only applies average below 80% of value, the reduction is measured against 80% of the value instead of the full value. Using the same warehouse:
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Full rebuild value | $1,000,000 |
| Required sum insured (80%) | $800,000 |
| Sum insured | $600,000 |
| Damage | $100,000 |
| Insurer pays ($600,000 ÷ $800,000 × $100,000) | $75,000, less the excess |
| Owner pays | $25,000, plus the excess |
The threshold softens the penalty but doesn’t remove it. If the sum insured had been $800,000 or more, the claim would have been paid in full, less the excess.
What is a declared value?
On ISR and other larger commercial policies, you declare the value of your property at the start of each policy period. That declared value is what the underinsurance clause is tested against: if it’s below the required percentage of the property’s actual value at the start of the period, average applies to your claims.
The policy also has a limit of liability, which is the most the insurer will pay. The two are set separately, so a generous limit of liability doesn’t protect you if your declared value is too low.
Why does underinsurance happen?
- Values not kept up to date: asset values change over time with inflation and market conditions, so a sum insured set years ago can fall behind.
- Changes not added to the policy: renovations, fit-outs, new equipment, extra stock or business expansion all increase what you need to insure.
- The wrong basis for the value: your policy may be based on replacement cost rather than market value, so check which applies before you set your figures.
How do you avoid the average clause?
- Review your sums insured annually and before each renewal: asset values change over time.
- Update after changes: renovations, improvements, new equipment, major purchases and business expansion should be reflected straight away.
- Get professional valuations: consider a professional valuation every 3 to 5 years for high-value assets.
- Check your policy documents: look for any average or underinsurance clause and how it affects your claims.
- Ask your broker: check whether your policy has an average clause, how much cover you need, and how to determine the current value of your assets.
Coverscope reviews sums insured and average conditions on commercial property, industrial special risks and business insurance policies, so you know where you stand before a claim, not after.
This article provides general information only and doesn’t constitute legal or personal financial advice. Average provisions vary between policies, so check your own policy wording.


